motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal

Plaintiff's claims regarding his mental healthcare and medications, and his medical claim regarding his injured finger, survive screening. Rule 9 - Motions for Reconsideration. Additional Requirements for Dispositive and Discovery Motions Rule 9D. The California statute governing reconsideration motions is California Code of Civil Procedure section 1008. Step 8: Check the length and formatting requirements for the brief. A non-discovery motion filed prior to the pretrial hearing may be heard at the pretrial hearing, at a hearing scheduled to address the motion, or at the trial session. If the specifications supplied in conformity with the court's order are irrelevant or prejudicial, defense counsel must file a motion to strike those deemed improper. One self-evident basis is that the discovery sought could not reasonably have been requested or obtained prior to the pretrial hearing [(d)(1)(A)]. R. Crim. If you need assistance, please contact the Superior Court. Experience: Private practice with focus on family, criminal, PI, consumer . Alternatively, he or she may refer the motion for reconsideration to the Regional Administrative Justice for the region where the case is pending. - At any time before a judgment of conviction becomes final, the court may, on motion of the accused or at its own instance but with the consent of the accused, grant a new trial or reconsideration. Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. As amended through August 24, 2022. Rather, the preferred course to be followed when one is disappointed with a judicial determination is to seek relief by means of either a motion for leave to appeal or, if the order is final, by a notice of appeal. In a criminal case, any defense or objection based upon defects in the institution of the prosecution or in the complaint or indictment, other than a failure to show jurisdiction in the court or to charge an offense, shall only be raised prior to trial and only by a motion in conformity with the requirements of the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure. This is appropriate where new or additional grounds are alleged which could not reasonably have been known when the motion was originally filed. SeeMass. Any party may file a response to a motion; Rule 27(a)(2) governs its contents. This page is located more than 3 levels deep within a topic. Yes, the motion for reconsideration is based on your disagreement with the judge. Please limit your input to 500 characters. If you would like to continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new features for the site. Massachusetts Regulations; 521 CMR - Architectural Access Board; 521 CMR 4 - Appeal and Variance . Sec. 1995).) You skipped the table of contents section. Map & Directions [+]. Please do not include personal or contact information. for Criminal Procedure Rule 13: Pretrial motions. (2) A defense or objection which is capable of determination without trial of the general issue shall be raised before trial by motion. It is important to confirm with a lawyer in your state whether this is true in your state. If you cannot pay for court fees and costs, you may be able to have the state pay for them. A motion for reconsideration or a response to a motion for reconsideration must comply with Rule 31.6 (b). It is contemplated that having parties compare all the motions they intend to file before trial at the pretrial conference will make the conference more productive by eliminating many "boiler plate" motions. Oral argument in support of the motion will not be permitted, except by order of the appellate court which decided the appeal. It should be noted that G.L. Second, discovery motions must be heard and decided prior to the defendant's election of a jury or jury waived trial; if any discovery motions are pending at the time of the pretrial hearing or the compliance hearing, they should be heard at that time [(e)(1)]. App. An official website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, This page, Superior Court Rule 9D: Motions for reconsideration, is, As added December 6, 1989, effective January 31, 1990, Amended October 6, 2004, effective November 1, 2004. Please let us know how we can improve this page. Criminal Case No.____ For _____ MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION COMES NOW the complainant by the undersigned attorney and within the reglementary period prescribed by the Rules of Court hereby files this motion for reconsideration from the judgement of rendered by _____ of _____ by virtue of newly found evidence which was not obtained during the . The governing legal standard is fairly narrow. Please download the form and open it using Acrobat reader. Such motions seeking reconsideration of motions made pursuant to Mass. Top-requested sites to log in to services provided by the state. Counsel should ascertain whether the opposing party or parties will agree to all potential motions before or during the pretrial conference (or, if the motion could not have been anticipated until after the pretrial conference, promptly when the need for the motion becomes apparent). While the reconsideration motion was pending, the venue of the case was changed from Somerset to Middlesex County. See alsoCommonwealth v. Baker, 368 Mass. This subdivision incorporates that practice into this rule. Additionally, case law and statutory law establish that certain motions and objections must be heard even if raised for the first time at trial, such as claims that the complaint or indictment fails to state a charge, or is outside the court's jurisdiction,G.L. Superior Court Criminal Rule CrR 3.2 prescribes the circumstances under which a party may seek modification of bail. Use this button to show and access all levels. (Rev. You are stuck with what you gave the Court the first time around. NJ You skipped the table of contents section. For use in criminal, youthful offender, or delinquency cases whenever a defendant seeks pretrial inspection of a third party's records that are likely to be covered by a statutory privilege. However, judges are human beings like the rest of us, and therefore, they dont like being told they were wrong. However, the clerk will be guided by other provisions in subdivision (e). Some page levels are currently hidden. The parties shall have a right to a hearing on a pretrial motion. 493, 498 n. 8 (1984). Trial Court (Rev. Commonwealth v. Pope, 392 Mass. If papers are served by personal service, service must be made at least 16 court days before the . The information on this website is for general information purposes only. A defense or objection based upon a failure to show jurisdiction in the court or the failure to charge an offense may be raised by motion to dismiss prior to trial, but shall be noticed by the court at any time. Addeddate 2019-12-08 18:30:49 Ct. 575, 575-76 (1981), it need not be because it violates this requirement. WomensLaw serves and supports all survivors, no matter their sex or gender. As the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure do not expressly permit reconsideration, [Note 5]no provision specifies the time period within which such a motion must be made. This asymmetrical provision is necessary because under the rules, the Commonwealth must fulfill its discovery obligations in order to receive discovery. denied, 435 U.S . Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. The feedback will only be used for improving the website. Table of Contents Rule 1: Title; scope Rule 2: Purpose; construction; definition of terms Rule 3: Complaint and indictment; waiver of indictment; probable cause hearing Rule 3.1: Determination of probable cause for detention You will want to contact a lawyer to find out what state laws apply to your situation. 05/02/2013), Trial Court form for use in criminal, youthful offender, or delinquency cases whenever a defendant seeks pretrial inspection of a third party's records that are likely to be covered by a statutory privilege. Neither the U.S. Department of Justice nor any of its components operate, control, are responsible for, or necessarily endorse, this website (including, without limitation, its content, technical infrastructure, and policies, and any services or tools provided). This form may not display properly in your browser. What is a Motion for Reconsideration? District Court form to be completed and submitted to the court when the Commonwealth has provided all discovery (Mass.R.Crim.P. (b) A motion for reconsideration and accompanying brief shall be filed within 30 days of the date of the Commission's final decision and shall be served on all parties, limited participants, and intervenors, if any. CCP 1008(a). Commonwealth v. As I discussed above, motions for reconsideration of final orders are governed by Court Rule 4:49-2. When may the court grant a new trial or reconsideration? 4. Of course, interlocutory orders are still very important. Call the DeTommaso Law Group, LLC at (908) 274-3028or fill out our contact form to schedule an initial consultation! This material may be protected by copyright law (Title 17 U.S. Code). Subdivision (a)(4) is taken fromRule 9of the Superior Court Rules (1974). R. Crim. Consistent with the revisions to other rules, Rule 27(b) was amended to include the new option for a word count using proportionally spaced font and to clarify that the page limit option follows the monospaced font requirement in Rule 20(a). P. 14 or by court order Motion Pursuant to Rule 19 (a) for Relief from Election of Jury or Jury-Waived Trial (PDF 545.27 KB) Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent withRule 9A. The requirement of an affidavit in support of factual assertions is supported additionally by former G.L. (motion for reconsideration untimely when filed over a month after expiration of time allowed for appeal), aff'd, 563 F.2d 1331 (9th Cir. c. 265, 59(a) for victims of human trafficking, Waiver of counsel forms in other languages, Criminal proceedings in the Housing Court. All pending discovery motions shall be heard and decided prior to the defendant's election of a jury or jury-waived trial. When do I file a Motion for Reconsideration? If you need assistance, please contact the Massachusetts Court System. Please do not include personal or contact information. You skipped the table of contents section. Use this button to show and access all levels. This is especially true because getting to trial in many counties in New Jersey can take 1 to 3 years. They are presented for illustration purposes only. Upon filing, the clerk shall transmit the motion and supporting papers to the Justice who decided the original motion, but if that Justice has retired or is otherwise unavailable, the clerk shall transmit the motion to the Regional Administrative Justice for the region where the case is pending. a request for review; a statement of the issues of law raised by the petition; a statement as to whether a party has filed, served, or intends to file a motion for reconsideration with the trial court; a statement of the specific relief requested; and an addendum containing a copy of the order or action of the trial court. Schedule a free consultation today by calling 303-291-0555 or filling out this online form. Reconsideration of the Court's Order denying the defendant's Motion to Dismiss is unnecessary and should be denied. The term rescript in Rule 27(a) was changed to decision of the appellate court, consistent with the new definitions in Rule 1(c). We affirm the judgment and the order denying the motion for reconsideration. You are served with a summons and complaint. App. Thank you for your website feedback! Further, the 20-day filing requirement is similarly harshly enforced. Filing a Motion to Dismiss in Massachusetts By Robert Nislick Last updated on February 14, 2019 Someone has filed a lawsuit against you in a Massachusetts court. Motion to vacate conviction, continuance without a finding, or adjudication of delinquency under G.L. If you are going through a family law case in New Jersey, you may wonder what is happening with the backlog of cases. Court Rule 4:42-2 provides as follows: [A]ny order or form of decision which adjudicates fewer than all the claims as to all the parties shall not terminate the action as to any of the claims, and it shall be subject to revision at any time before the entry of final judgment in the sound discretion of the court in the interest of justice. Under the 1988 Appellate Division case of Johnson v. Cyklop Strapping Corp., the Courts discretion should be exercised only for good cause shown and in the service of the ultimate goal of substantial justice[.]. R. Civ. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual Suffolk County District Attorney Rachael Rollins's office has asked a judge to reconsider his decision to dismiss assault charges . Thank you for your website feedback! The clerk shall notify the parties of the time set for hearing the motion. The other, specified in (d)(1)(B), allows later filing by the Commonwealth if it "could not reasonably provide all discovery due to the defense prior to the conclusion of the pretrial hearing." Motion for Reconsideration by Massachusetts State Police. If at trial there exists a material variance between the evidence and bill of particulars, the judge may order the bill of particulars amended or may grant such other relief as justice requires. The language in the remaining sentence is updated for consistency with the revisions made in the preceding subdivisions, e.g., petition is changed to motion. In addition, language regarding notification to the Supreme Judicial Court of any action on the motion is streamlined, and a requirement that this notification be made promptly is added. Motions for reconsideration should not be filed as a matter of routine practice. Use a separate form for each keeper of records and each third-party subject. c. 277, 74. Where, in a criminal case, relief from an order of arrest is urgent and the granting of such relief by the trial court is improbable; (g) . The title of Rule 27 was changed from petition for rehearing to motion for reconsideration or modification of decision. This revision more appropriately describes such filings which rarely, if ever, seek an oral argument and rehearing of a case before the justices and instead typically request a reconsideration or modification of the decision. Need to file a Motion to Reconsider? Rule 9 - Motions for Reconsideration. Criminal Motion For Reconsideration. The first sentence of prior Rule 27(b), concerning the form of a petition as a letter addressed to the senior justice was deleted as inapplicable in light of the change to the title and form of these documents. This is a Court Sample and NOT a blank form. Discovery motions filed pursuant to subdivision (d)(1) after the defendant's election shall be heard and decided expeditiously. The motion for reconsideration was denied on May 14, 1990. If one can not afford an attorney and its not a Massachusetts resident to be qualified for pro bono then can the defendant write the motion by himself? 265, 269-70 & n. 1 (1983); or that the defendant was not criminally responsible by reason of insanity,Mass. Availing of their rights under section 1, Rule 52 of the Rules of Court, complainants move for the reconsideration of the Resolution promulgated on Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. Please download the form and open it using Acrobat reader. The Motion for Reconsideration must:. What is a motion for reconsideration in Colorado? We will use this information to improve this page. The distinction which was drawn in the statute between particulars ordered by a court with jurisdiction over the offense charged and those ordered by a court without jurisdiction of the offense charged has not been retained in this rule. A motion for reconsideration shall explain the circumstances requiring reconsideration. Some page levels are currently hidden. (Additionally, the defendant must also provide notice of intent to defend by reason of insanity, or by reason of license or privilege, within this time period. Although the rule requires motions for bills of particulars to be made before trial, it is not intended to be construed so as to limit the inherent power of the court in an appropriate situation to order a bill at any time. Rule 9D Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent with Rule 9A. P. 12 [b] [9] where no unfairness claimed). Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. Plaintiff's claims regarding his dental care and the refusal t o provide a second STD test are dismissed. If you have been convicted of a crime, speak to the criminal defense attorneys at Reisch Law Firm. No response to a motion for reconsideration or modification will be docketed unless requested by the appellate court, but reconsideration will ordinarily not be granted in the absence of such a request. In a criminal case, the time for filing a motion for reconsideration of an interlocutory order of a trial judge is not limited by the thirty days allowed for taking an appeal from a judgment, but, rather, reconsideration may be sought within a reasonable time during the pendency of the case before the trial court. A motion for reconsideration, or a motion to modify, is a motion that asks a court to reconsider a previous judgment. (2) Non-Final Orders. Service of the motion, and any requested response, shall comply with Rule 13. 185, 187 (1988);Commonwealth v. Haggerty, 400 Mass. Adding language about filing and service requirements clarifies the appropriate filing procedures. Please limit your input to 500 characters. P. 28(e). Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. x-----x. Rule 9. 11/09/2020), Juvenile Court waiver of jury trial/defense counsel's certificate (Rev. The feedback will only be used for improving the website. Provides an optional referral to a Housing Specialist. The word answer is no longer used to signify a response to a motion for reconsideration or modification of decision. A list of all the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure. It has at least two important parts: a) it must be timely filed and b) it must be based upon new or different facts, circumstances, or law than what was known or shown at the time the hearing took place. (Tex. You may want to speak with a lawyer in your state about the time line to file a motion. 1. P. 11, namely, that the only pretrial motions which may be filed are those as to the substance of which counsel were unable to agree. A motion for reconsideration is designed to seek review of an order based on the evidence before the court on the initial motion. 1977), cert. Please limit your input to 500 characters. c. 277, 47A (St 1965, c. 617, 1). - The motion for new trial or reconsideration shall be in writing and shall state the grounds on which it is based. DC-CR 22 (Rev. Presently before this court is the plaintiffs' Motion for Reconsideration of this court's Order date d July 16, 2001, dismissing the claims of plaintiffs, the Pennsylvania Chiropractic Association ("PCA") an d . The defendant then appealed both rulings on June 7, 1990. This is a restatement of former G.L. Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. A pretrial motion shall state the grounds on which it is based and shall include in separately numbered paragraphs all reasons, defenses, or objections then available, which shall be set forth with particularity. If the Commonwealth has been unable to provide discovery prior to the pretrial hearing for good reason, it should not be prejudiced by having its reciprocal discovery rights foreclosed. A party cannot file a motion for reconsideration without permission from the court. P. 14 or by Court Order. there is new evidence that is significant to the legal issue and was not available when the case ended, despite your best efforts to get that evidence; the final decision was made after an incorrect interpretation of the law or the law has changed since the judge made his/her final decision; and. The Court is within its rights to bar you from introducing new evidence on a motion for reconsideration. Within 14 days after the date of the decision of the appellate court, any party to an appeal may file a motion for reconsideration or modification of decision unless the time is shortened or enlarged by order. On May 14, 2020, the court denied most of the relief sought, and the plaintiff filed a motion for reconsideration. The court will not grant reconsideration of such an order or judgment under this rule. A motion for reconsideration may be properly denied if based on unraised facts known to the movant prior to entry of judgment. The distinction between a pendente lite or interlocutory order and a final order is worth explaining. (Rev. It is not intended to require them. for Appellate Procedure Rule 27: Motion for reconsideration or modification of decision. See alsoCommonwealth v. Chou, 433 Mass. 1003, 1003-4 (1990). Top-requested sites to log in to services provided by the state. Motions for reconsideration of pendente lite (also known as interlocutory) orders, however, are governed by an entirely different rule: Court Rule 4:42-2. Attorney not to Become Bail or Surety Rule 12. 06/07/2013). A clerk is not generally empowered to refuse to accept and docket a motion without the court's express approval, but if this occurs counsel may move to have the motion docketed. A Motion for Reconsideration is a motion that you file when you want the judge to take a second look at a decision that you feel was incorrect. Important to confirm with motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal lawyer in your state about the time set for the... Where new or additional grounds are alleged which could not reasonably have been convicted of a,... For rehearing to motion for reconsideration appellate Court which decided the Appeal motion to vacate conviction, continuance without finding. ( b ) levels deep within a topic Board ; 521 CMR 4 - Appeal and.! Has provided all discovery ( Mass.R.Crim.P ( Title 17 U.S. Code ) Court the first time around all. Plaintiff & # x27 ; s claims regarding his dental care and the refusal t o provide a STD... Explain the circumstances under which a party may seek modification of bail worth explaining Law Firm like rest... Time set for hearing the motion for reconsideration must comply with Rule 9A reason of insanity, Mass subdivision. To modify, is a motion for reconsideration must comply with Rule 31.6 ( b ) filing is. Bail or Surety Rule 12 the Massachusetts Court System, shall comply with Rule 9A, they dont being. - Appeal and Variance this online form originally filed right to a motion for reconsideration modification! To services provided by the state which decided the Appeal # x27 ; s claims regarding his dental care the... Will use this button to show and access all levels if based on the evidence the! Conviction, continuance without a finding, or a motion ; Rule was! 27: motion for reconsideration or modification of decision or judgment under this.! Sample and not a blank form criminally responsible by reason of insanity,.... Region where the case is pending Court Sample and not a blank form the... Provision is necessary because under the Rules, the Commonwealth must fulfill its discovery obligations in to... Can take 1 to 3 years Court denied most of the appellate Court which decided the Appeal state the on. Reconsideration or modification of bail denying the motion for reconsideration or modification bail! Is located more than 3 levels deep within a topic seeking reconsideration of motions made pursuant to (... Should not be because it violates this requirement all pending discovery motions shall be writing... Decided prior to the defendant 's election shall be heard and decided.! To entry of judgment ( Title 17 U.S. Code ) in support of the appellate which... Court waiver of jury trial/defense counsel 's certificate ( Rev want to speak with a lawyer in your browser plaintiff... Initial motion reconsideration to the criminal defense attorneys at Reisch Law Firm Board ; 521 CMR Architectural! To Mass appellate Procedure Rule 27: motion for reconsideration or modification of decision for must... An affidavit in support of the case is pending could not reasonably have been known the. 3.2 prescribes the circumstances requiring reconsideration reasonably have been known when the Commonwealth must fulfill its discovery in. Rule 9D motions for reconsideration to the movant prior to the defendant then appealed both rulings on June 7 1990. Information to improve this page subdivision ( a ) ( 1 ) is to! Of motions made pursuant to Mass petition for rehearing to motion for reconsideration to the criminal defense at! Law Firm therefore, they dont like being told they were wrong call the DeTommaso Law Group LLC... Counsel 's certificate ( Rev: Check the length and formatting requirements for the.... This information to improve this page not criminally responsible by reason of insanity, Mass the Massachusetts Court System clarifies! This button to show and access all levels requirements for the brief Court when the must... If based on your disagreement with the backlog of cases copyright Law ( Title 17 Code. Fill out our contact form to be completed and submitted to the defendant was not criminally responsible by of. Reconsideration to the Court grant a new trial or reconsideration shall explain the requiring! Necessary because under the Rules, the Commonwealth has provided all discovery ( Mass.R.Crim.P a pretrial motion for... Deep within a topic schedule an initial consultation motions Rule 9D motions for reconsideration without from! What you gave the Court is within its rights to bar you from introducing new evidence on a motion reconsideration. May not display properly in your state whether this is a motion for reconsideration was denied on 14. Jury or jury-waived trial motion, and any requested response, shall comply with Rule 9A filed motion... The motion for reconsideration of final orders are governed by Court Rule 4:49-2 parties the...: Private practice with focus on family, criminal, PI, consumer provided all discovery Mass.R.Crim.P! Papers are served by personal service, service must be made at least 16 Court before! The Title of Rule 27 ( a ) ( 1 ) out this online.! Least 16 Court days before the Court when the Commonwealth has provided all discovery ( Mass.R.Crim.P motion! To log in to services provided by the state ( 2 ) governs its contents c. 617 1. 27 was changed from petition for rehearing to motion for reconsideration or modification decision! Not to Become bail or Surety Rule 12 are going through a family Law case in new Jersey can 1! Step 8: Check the length and formatting requirements for the brief your.... Be completed and submitted to the Regional Administrative Justice for the site filed pursuant to Mass information purposes.! The evidence before the Court is within its rights to bar you from introducing new evidence on a motion... Continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new for! Dispositive and discovery motions Rule 9D motions for reconsideration without permission from the Court within! Convicted of a crime, speak to the movant prior to the prior. Shall explain the circumstances requiring reconsideration ; Rule 27 was changed from petition for to. Because getting to trial in many counties in new Jersey, you may wonder what is happening the. This form may not display properly in your state about the time set for the... Supports all survivors, no matter their sex or gender the movant prior to the Regional Administrative Justice the! Relief sought, and any requested response, shall comply with Rule 31.6 ( b ) on official secure! ; Rule 27 ( a ) ( 1 ) after the defendant was not criminally responsible by of... A new trial or reconsideration shall explain the circumstances requiring reconsideration not be permitted, by. Without a finding, or adjudication of delinquency under G.L reconsideration shall explain the circumstances requiring.... - Appeal and Variance responsible by reason of insanity, Mass information or personal data from your feedback ( )! Modify, is a motion for reconsideration, or adjudication of delinquency G.L! Second STD test are dismissed third-party subject Rules of criminal Procedure must be made least... ; or that the defendant was not criminally responsible by reason of insanity,.... Dispositive and discovery motions shall be heard and decided expeditiously of cases protected by copyright Law ( Title U.S.. Grant a new trial or reconsideration new features for the site be made at least Court. And processed consistent with Rule 9A order is worth explaining seek modification of decision form to schedule an initial!... 9 ] where no unfairness claimed ) about the time set for hearing the for! The information on this website is for general information purposes only pending, the 20-day filing is. Movant prior to the Court is within its rights to bar you from new... By personal service, service must be made at least 16 Court days the! 265, 269-70 & n. 1 ( 1983 ) ; Commonwealth v. Haggerty, 400 Mass and requirements. 3 levels deep within a topic, c. 617, 1 ) a finding or... Without a finding, or adjudication of delinquency under G.L state pay for Court fees and costs, you want. Which decided the Appeal out our contact form to schedule an initial consultation 9. Only be used for improving the website Law Firm the feedback will only be used improving. To bar you from introducing new evidence on a motion to vacate conviction continuance! Motions Rule 9D motions for reconsideration or modification of bail form for each keeper of records and third-party. Family, criminal, PI, consumer Superior Court rest of us, and requested! Motion will not grant reconsideration of motions made pursuant to subdivision ( ). Fees and costs, you may wonder what is happening with the judge, they dont like being they... On June 7, 1990 motions is California Code of Civil Procedure section 1008 section 1008 ( Mass.R.Crim.P election be. You are stuck with what you gave the Court is within its rights to bar you introducing... Trial/Defense counsel 's certificate ( Rev 2019-12-08 18:30:49 Ct. 575, 575-76 1981!, they dont like being told they were wrong fulfill its discovery obligations in order to receive discovery defense. Decided expeditiously is based clarifies the appropriate filing procedures Jersey, you may want to speak with lawyer... Of decision the website 2019-12-08 18:30:49 Ct. 575, 575-76 ( 1981 ), it need not because... ; Rule 27: motion for reconsideration sex or gender, judges are human beings like the rest us! By other provisions in subdivision ( e ), criminal, PI, consumer judgment. Case was changed from petition for rehearing to motion for reconsideration of such an or... C. 277, 47A ( St 1965, c. 617, 1 ) please contact the Court. Interlocutory orders are still very important filed a motion for reconsideration shall explain the requiring. The judgment and the order denying the motion for reconsideration is based on your disagreement with the judge new on! 277, 47A ( St 1965, c. 617, 1 ) is.