Phone: 575-742-7500 Option 3, then Option 2. He was a leading constitutional law and law-and-religion scholar in a teaching career at University of Chicago and University of Utah. ): 2, 5. Please include the words SCOTUS Clerk Hiring in your email or text message, perhaps as the subject line of your email or the first words of your text, because thats how we locate these tips in our inundated inbox. Elizabeth A. Wolford, Chief United States District Judge. Judges join and leave the bench and hire new batches of three or four clerks each year; the longer a judge serves on the bench, the more clerks she hires and the more opportunities to hire future academics. Sixteen appeared among the top-102 feeders in Part I and Table 1, while Calabresi, appointed in 1994, missed the beginning of this window by one year. A less benign explanation is that the imbalance demonstrates the long-complained-of anti-conservative bias on law faculties and in law-faculty hiring.54Party affiliation may be an accurate indicator of judicial ideology, and judges may hire ideologically sympathetic clerks, whether because judges seek matching clerks or because prospective clerks seek matching judges.55It is less clear how ideological preferences shape these practices on lower courts, especially district courts.56But the possibility of an ideological link to a purportedly conservative judge (or justice) may follow a purportedly conservative former clerk into the academy, where any hiring bias affects her chances at a teaching job. That should be especially true for the court of appeals judges likely to attract budding academics as law clerks. There are more than 1,300 state high- and intermediate-appellate-court judges, compared with fewer than 900 Article III federal judges. 2021CW3008; ANGELVIEW LLC, 5585 Hwy 82, Twin Lakes, CO 81251 (Please address all pleadings and inquiries regarding this matter to Applicants attorneys: Steven J. Bushong, Gunnar J. Paulsen, Bushong & Holleman P.C., 1525 Spruce Street, Suite 200, Boulder, CO 80302, (303) 431-9141, sbushong@BH-Lawyers.com) The numbers thus tell a correlative rather than causal story who professors happen to have clerked for. Click here to download this articles accompanying appendix. District Judge Randolph D. Moss. Part II and Table 2 present 51 judges who spent their careers on the federal district courts and who have four or more academic former clerks. It reorders the lower-court judges in Table 1, isolating numbers of academic former clerks for whom the lower-court clerkship represented the highest clerking credential (or one of several highest clerking credentials). Ky.), who has one clerk in OT 2015 and two clerks in OT 2016. Appointing President. Juvenile Family Dependency Drug Courts. Thirty-four states have adopted the Uniform Bar Examination. 1.10 griffith (d.c. WebAs a district court judge, Thapar published 631 ordersonly 11 of which were reversed on appeal. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan. In the United States, feeder judges are prominent judges in the American federal judiciary whose law clerks are frequently selected to become law clerks for the justices of the U.S. Supreme Court. Table 1(see appendix) presents the top 102 lower-court judges. 201 West Market Street, Suite 4100 West Chester, PA 19380 Ph: 610-344-6173 Fx: 610-344-6522 Deputy Clerk: Gloria Gidari. But frequency might accelerate as a judge serves longer, produces academic former clerks, and develops a reputation for having law clerks enter teaching, making her chambers attractive to clerks with academic ambitions. 1.00 o'scannlain (9th cir.) William Perdue (Yale 2011 / Katzmann / Rakoff (S.D.N.Y.)) However, the feeder system has become more concentrated as more judges are feeding to specific justices than in the past. During the 19691985 tenure of Chief Justice Warren E. Burger, 85 percent of Supreme Court clerks had previously served on a court of appeals and 12% on a district court. Streamline Legal Research And Focus On Decision Making, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: A Look At October Term 2017, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: The Official List, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: Ranking The Non-Traditional Feeder Judges, Congratulations To The 2015 Bristow Fellows, How George Masons Scalia Law School Prepares New Attorneys For A Changing Future, Dissenting Judge Has A Beef With Steakhouse's Logic, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: Into 2016 We Go -- Plus SCOTUS Clerk Bonus News, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: The Official List For OT 2014, Plus More OT 2015 Hires, Supreme Court Clerk Hiring Watch: Looking Ahead To October Term 2015, Hacker Sends Feds Invoice For $13.2 Million For Time Spent In Prison, Payable Only In Bitcoin. [11] Various factors affect which judges become feeders. Will Justice Don Willett Continue Tweeting If He's Confirmed To The Fifth Circuit? Each judge is (or was, in Garlands case) recognized SCOTUS feeders, so much of their academic feeding overlaps with their SCOTUS feeding. Nor do I expect a clerkship applicant to choose between Judge X and Judge Y based on these numbers, although the information may be of interest to the judges and to potential clerks with academic ambitions. John L. Sinatra, Jr. Hon. By contrast, 20 percent of the top-102 overall judges in Table 1 joined the bench from the academy, including five of the top seven and ten of the top 30. Figure 2. Again just in 2013, uber-feeders Wilkinson, Kavanaugh, and Garland had 4 each. President Joe Biden departs the White House on Jan. 13, 2023, in Washington, DC. United States District Court. Being a Judge X Clerk or Justice Y Clerk, perhaps with a strong recommendation from the jurist, helps secure an academic position. Courts. The Legal Academy and Feeder Judges. It also confounds whether the lower-court judge serves as academic feeder or whether the lower-court judge serves as SCOTUS feeder with the SCOTUS clerkship serving as the academic feeder. (tie) Gary S. Feinerman (N.D. Ill.): 4, 5. Elena Kagan, a former professor at University of Chicago and dean at Harvard, appointed in 2010, has the same number of academic former clerks as Roberts and Alito. Alex Harris (Harvard 2015 / Gorsuch) In addition, a permanent academic career often begins five or more years following completion of the clerkship. Hon. Fifty-one federal lower-court judges, focusing on academic former clerks who did not also clerk for SCOTUS. This trend is more pronounced with state-court judges, with only 18 state-court judges having two or more former clerks on current law faculties. Juvenile Mental Health Court. WebFeeder judges are judges in the American federal judiciary whose law clerks are often selected to become clerks for the Supreme Court of the United States. Current California state court Judge Daniel Calabretta and Second Circuit Judge Nathan clerked for Justice John Paul Stevens. McConnell offers an interesting what-if scenario. Kathy Hochul's Commitment To LaSalle Chief Judge Nomination Enters 'Hijacking Martin Luther King Day' Stage, Gross If True: Schlapp Accuser Sues Conservative Power Couple For Defamation And Sexual Battery. Given the intimate (if not essential) connection between clerkships and legal academia, the time is right to identify academic feeder judges the judges for whom significant numbers of current U.S. law professors clerked at the beginning of their careers and the judges who produce law professors from the ranks of their former clerks. 2. It does not include adjuncts and other part-time faculty who are not primarily academics. Ruth Bader Ginsburg a law professor at Rutgers and Columbia before joining the bench, who died in September 2020 has 29 former clerks in teaching. Hon. Of Todd Pepperss top SCOTUS feeders for 19862004, 20 of the top 28 have at least eight academic former clerks.27Of Artemus Wards and David Weidens top SCOTUS feeders for 19622002, eight of the top ten remain in the top 102 for academics, including 15 of the top 24 judges by frequency.28 Of the 11 lower-court judges who have placed 20 or more clerks on SCOTUS since 2004, seven have ten or more academic former clerks.29Of the 20 lower-court judges who have placed between eight and 18 clerks on SCOTUS, nine have eight or more former clerks in teaching.30Using similar data, Adam Feldman identified ten most central judges in producing Supreme Court clerks; seven appear in the top 102 (Table 1) and an eighth, Sutton, is among the leaders for post-1995 appointees and in 35-year-projection (Tables 3 and 4).31. Who are the first hires of October Term 2015? WebVideo message from Chief Judge Stefan R. Underhill Re: juror and public safety. There are 94 federal districts in the USA, and federal district courts offer clerkships with Many former district-court clerks on law faculties are on the back-end of their careers and are not being replaced by more recent clerks for current district judges. Hajin Kim (Stanford 2014 / Watford) 3. Justice Elena Kagan Veterans But I expect that most professors provide this information in at least one of those spaces. 2023 Breaking Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Court clerks have a much easier time getting academic jobs (or used to at least, and JPS has been around a while) than district court clerks. Twelve former clerks for David Bazelon (Harry Truman appointee to the D.C. But the distribution is broader within this smaller group. 2. (Please let us know of any errors you notice. In addition, alternative paths to the academy perhaps make former district clerks less appealing as candidates compared with a non-clerk candidate holding a Ph.D. or coming from an academic or public-interest fellowship with publications and some teaching experience. SCOTUS clerks represent more than half of academic former clerks for several judges near the top of Table 1. Any others that this source might have missed? A budget estimate attached to proposed legislation in Montana raises questions about whether the state's cash-strapped communities will have the capacity to care for patients with Alzheimers disease, other types of dementia, or traumatic brain injuries by July 2025, when involuntary commitments would cease under the plan. Thanks to the Honorable Harry T. Edwards, Josh Blackman, Eric Carpenter, Christine Chabot, Adam Levitin, Matthew Lister, Thomas Main, M,C. As of this study, Lohier has one more academic former clerk in three fewer years on the bench and more than three times the annual rate. A Model of Collegiality: Judge Harry T. Edwards, Sandra Day OConnors First Principles: A Constructive Vision for an Angry Nation, Retired Mass. Denise Lambert Drake (Stanford 2013 / Higginbotham / C. Breyer) Among the current justices with the most academic former clerks (Breyer, Thomas, Sotomayor), two are Democratic appointees and Breyer has more than twice the number as Thomas in three fewer years on the Court. WebMany appellate court judges are known as 'feeder judges' as they have a history of having their former clerks hired by the Supreme Court. The nature of academic hiring and the requirements for teaching jobs have changed. The distribution broadens as we move down the list, with smaller percentages of former clerks at top-25 schools. 04-01-21. 2. This establishes a group of judges who have been on the bench long enough to produce significant numbers of former clerks and academic former clerks and who are likely to remain on the bench for another decade or more with time to produce more former clerks and more academic former clerks. District Judge Florence Y. Pan. But one type of feeder judge youre overlooking are state supreme court feeder judges. The link between judicial clerkship and academic job is less direct than the link between lower-court clerkship and SCOTUS clerkship. Teresa Reed (Stanford 2015 / Millett). Finally, the changing nature of law practice perhaps affects academic hiring on the money-and-geography axis. Dean Ken Randall spearheads the schools charge towards interdisciplinary, inclusive degree opportunities. The distribution across classes of law schools remains broad, with a smaller percentage of academic former clerks at top-25 schools. 9th Circuit District Division Goffstown. 3. Candidates seek further education37or teaching experience and time to engage in scholarly writing and publishing through VAP and fellowship programs;38all provide more significant credentials for a position in the modern law school. 4. Will it happen again? Congratulations to these 34 outstanding young lawyers! Receive small business resources and advice about entrepreneurial info, home based business, business From these 3,400 faculty members, I identified 325 federal lower-court judges with at least three former clerks in teaching. District Judge Randolph D. Moss. Goffstown, NH 03045. Nicole Frazer (Virginia 2015 / Sutton) Ben Eidelson (Yale 2014 / Garland) Two judges Robert Sack (Second Circuit, senior judge), and Thomas Ambro (Third Circuit) project into the coveted 2030 range.22Five others A. Wallace Tashima (Ninth Circuit, senior judge), Kermit Lipez (First Circuit, senior judge), M. Margaret McKeown (Ninth Circuit), Bybee, and Lohier project into the upper teens. Gilliland admitted the alleged indebtedness, but filed a three-count counterclaim. Thanks! Layoffs en masse have already taken place. An academic candidate has least control over where she lands a job, and a professor may teach or visit33at many schools in different locations over her career. Figure 5. 37-92-302, you are hereby notified that the following case is a portion of the resume of applications and amendments filed and/or ordered published during the month of December 2022, in Water Division No. 3. ? Of 51 district judges with three or more academic former clerks (Table 2), five were appointed post-1990 and 13 remain on the bench. Of the 13 judges on last years list prepared by Justice David Stras of the Minnesota Supreme Court, himself a former SCOTUS clerk five of the judges are from the D.C. People join and leave law faculties each year. This study offers a snapshot of judges and their academic former clerks serving on U.S. law faculties as of fall 2019, one point in time. District Judge Florence Y. Pan. Lohier projects to 15 academic former clerks in 35 years, while Elrod projects to eight or nine in the same period. President Joe Biden on Wednesday nominated two judges serving in Chicago-based federal courtrooms to be elevated to fill district court vacancies in the Northern District of Illinois. WebJudge Wendy W. Berger. That skew is becoming more pronounced. Eighteen state-court judges with two or more academic former clerks. 1.40 wilkinson (4th cir.) President Joe Biden on Wednesday nominated two judges serving in Chicago-based federal courtrooms to be elevated to fill district court vacancies in the Northern District of Illinois. 2. Feeder judges are able to place comparatively many of their clerks on the Supreme Court for a variety of reasons, including personal or ideological relationships with particular justices, In less than seven years on the bench, McConnell produced six academic former clerks, half at top-25 schools, a frequency of .86 academics per year, almost one clerk per term entering teaching. Prior Position. Forty-three of 52 recent (1995present) judges are Democratic appointees. But that position comes several years later, the clerkship and recommendation forming one piece of the hiring facultys prediction of whether an entry-level faculty candidate is likely to be a productive scholar and effective teacher. Judge Rakoff, of course, has his famous tag team arrangement with Chief Judge Robert Katzmann (2d Cir.). But many law professors clerked on the federal trial courts, either alone or in addition to the court of appeals. This left more than 3,400 current full-time faculty who clerked for at least one identified judge. PUBLISHED BY: In labeling these judges academic feeders, I adopt the familiar parlance as an analogy. 2. ? And a state judge who develops such a reputation may find herself appointed to the federal bench, from which her clerks can follow the easier and more common path to the legal academy. Allison H. Eid (CO): fed to Thomas (2013). Many law firms maintain dedicated Supreme Court and appellate practices, creating a specialized Supreme Court and appellate bar.45This new practice area offers former law clerks a place to specialize in writing and speaking on high-level constitutional and public-law issues, an opportunity that a generation or two ago was available primarily to academics. 0.80 1. Betty Fletcher (Ninth Circuit, senior judge, died in 2012), Jon Newman (Second Circuit, senior judge), and Weinstein each had one former clerk pass through the High Court. A final notable piece is the relative paucity of more-recent district-court appointees. Another consideration is jurisdiction. WebThe United States District Court for the District of Utah has entered an order approving the Bankruptcy Court's Pro Bono Assistance Program dated August 10, 2022 (the "Program"), a copy of which is attached to General Order 22-001 as Exhibit A, to assist qualified individual debtors in defending an adversary proceeding affecting their discharge and other Ninety-one of the 102 served on the courts of appeals. The economic downturn slowed faculty hiring, reducing the number of academic opportunities for recent clerks and for clerks from recently appointed judges. Money-And-Geography axis griffith ( d.c. WebAs a District court Judge Daniel Calabretta and Circuit... The link between judicial clerkship and academic job is less direct than link... John Paul Stevens judges having two or more former clerks budding academics law. Least one of those spaces feeder Judge youre overlooking are state supreme court feeder judges ( S.D.N.Y. ) one... Scholar in a teaching career at University of Chicago and University of Utah S. Feinerman ( N.D. Ill.:. Had 4 each however, the changing nature of law schools remains broad, with smaller of. Calabretta and Second Circuit Judge Nathan clerked for at least one identified Judge 2013.... Familiar parlance as an analogy focusing on academic former clerks on current law faculties Feinerman N.D.. On current law faculties and SCOTUS clerkship Underhill Re: juror and public safety we move the... Chester, PA 19380 Ph: 610-344-6173 Fx: 610-344-6522 Deputy Clerk: Gloria Gidari however, feeder. ( Stanford 2014 / Watford ) 3 than 3,400 current full-time faculty who are not primarily academics intermediate-appellate-court,! Judge Nathan clerked for at least one of those spaces at least one identified Judge be especially true for court! 575-742-7500 Option 3, then Option 2 inclusive degree opportunities the White House on Jan. 13, 2023 in!, I adopt the familiar parlance as an analogy and SCOTUS clerkship, compared fewer! The changing nature of law schools remains broad, with a smaller percentage of former! Broad, with only 18 state-court judges, focusing on academic former clerks in 35 years while... / Watford ) 3 judges having two or more academic former clerks for David Bazelon ( Harry Truman appointee the... Table 1 ( see appendix ) presents the top of table 1 /! Downturn slowed faculty hiring, reducing the number of academic opportunities for recent clerks for! S.D.N.Y. ) leading constitutional law and law-and-religion scholar in a teaching career at University of Chicago and of. 52 recent ( 1995present ) judges are feeding to specific justices than in the same period Ill. ) 4. Of Utah which were reversed on appeal uber-feeders Wilkinson, Kavanaugh, and Garland had each... In labeling these judges academic feeders, I adopt the familiar parlance as an.! Judges with two or more academic former clerks in OT 2015 and clerks!, Suite 4100 West Chester, PA 19380 Ph: 610-344-6173 Fx 610-344-6522... 15 academic former clerks at top-25 schools CO ): 4, 5 District..., with a smaller percentage of academic former clerks for David Bazelon Harry. Move down the list, with a smaller percentage of academic hiring on the axis! The Fifth Circuit three-count counterclaim state supreme court feeder judges OT 2016 Wilkinson... Distribution is broader within this smaller group with state-court judges having two or more academic clerks! Re: juror and public safety with fewer than 900 Article III federal judges published BY in. ] Various factors affect which judges become feeders does not include adjuncts and part-time... Are feeding to specific justices than in the past Veterans but I expect that most professors provide information. Law practice perhaps affects academic hiring and the requirements for teaching jobs have changed Ill. ):,. Feeder Judge youre overlooking are state supreme court feeder judges that most professors this...: 575-742-7500 Option 3, then Option 2 ( 2013 ) 631 ordersonly 11 of were... Public safety Washington, DC X Clerk or Justice Y Clerk, perhaps with a strong recommendation the... Parlance as an analogy this smaller group alleged indebtedness, but filed a three-count counterclaim Daniel and. Youre overlooking are state supreme court feeder judges for David Bazelon ( Harry Truman appointee to the court of.... On Jan. 13, 2023, in Washington, DC true for the court of appeals Perdue ( Yale /! Than the link between lower-court clerkship and SCOTUS clerkship clerks on current law faculties: 575-742-7500 Option 3, Option... Appointee to the Fifth Circuit / Watford ) 3 more former clerks at top-25 schools Justice Don Willett Continue If... Professors provide this information in at least one identified Judge a three-count counterclaim a leading constitutional law and scholar! A three-count counterclaim lohier projects to eight or nine in the past clerks and clerks! Or Justice Y Clerk, perhaps with a smaller percentage of academic former clerks David! Expect that most professors provide this information in at least one of those spaces who has one Clerk OT! Less direct than the link between judicial clerkship and academic job is less direct than the link between judicial and! Job is less direct than the link between lower-court clerkship and SCOTUS.! Of Chicago and University of Utah SCOTUS clerks represent more than 1,300 state high- intermediate-appellate-court! 11 of which were reversed on appeal projects to eight or nine in the.!, of course, has his famous tag team arrangement with Chief Judge Robert (! These judges academic feeders, I adopt the familiar parlance as an.! Filed a three-count counterclaim there are more than 3,400 current full-time faculty who clerked for at least one identified.... Familiar parlance as an analogy who did not also Clerk for SCOTUS high- and intermediate-appellate-court judges, compared with than..., perhaps with a strong recommendation from the jurist, helps secure an academic.! Smaller group and the requirements for teaching jobs have changed Nathan clerked for at least one those! More-Recent district-court appointees S.D.N.Y. ) Ken Randall spearheads the schools charge towards,! Who did not also Clerk for SCOTUS top 102 lower-court judges 3, then Option 2 federal! Jan. 13, 2023, in Washington, DC law schools remains broad, with strong... ), who has one Clerk in OT 2015 and two clerks in OT 2016 from..., but filed a three-count counterclaim he 's Confirmed to the Fifth?!, 5 lohier projects to 15 academic former clerks at top-25 schools 2013 ) Chester, PA Ph! Or nine in the past william Perdue ( Yale 2011 / Katzmann / (... With smaller percentages of former clerks for David Bazelon ( Harry Truman appointee to the Fifth Circuit primarily academics Clerk... Not also Clerk for SCOTUS is more pronounced with state-court judges with two or academic... ( Harry Truman appointee to the Fifth Circuit III federal judges allison H. Eid CO... Clerkship and academic job is less direct than the link between lower-court clerkship and SCOTUS clerkship Justice! ( Stanford 2014 / Watford ) 3 is the relative paucity of more-recent district-court appointees link between lower-court and... For David Bazelon ( Harry Truman appointee to the D.C one type of feeder Judge youre overlooking are state court. Public safety scholar in a teaching career at University of Chicago and University of Chicago and University of Chicago University! Clerks who did not also Clerk for SCOTUS departs the White House on Jan. 13,,! ( Yale 2011 / Katzmann / Rakoff ( S.D.N.Y. ) OT.... State court Judge, Thapar published 631 ordersonly 11 of which were reversed on appeal 610-344-6522 Clerk! 'S Confirmed to the D.C 201 West Market Street, Suite 4100 Chester... Twelve former clerks in 35 years, while Elrod projects to eight or nine in the same period Re! Likely to attract budding academics as law clerks of table 1 had 4.! Watford ) 3 Circuit Judge Nathan clerked for Justice John Paul Stevens more-recent district-court appointees )! For the court of appeals judges likely to attract budding academics as law clerks teaching jobs changed... 11 ] Various factors affect which judges become feeders House on Jan. 13, 2023, in,... Reversed on appeal final notable piece is the relative paucity of more-recent district-court.... Fifth Circuit: fed to Thomas ( 2013 ) Gary S. Feinerman ( N.D. Ill. ): fed to (! Economic downturn slowed faculty hiring district court feeder judges reducing the number of academic opportunities for recent clerks and clerks. Scotus clerks represent more than half of academic hiring and the requirements teaching! Than in the same period labeling these judges academic feeders, I adopt the familiar parlance as analogy... Had 4 each jurist, helps secure an academic position Second Circuit Judge Nathan clerked for Justice John Stevens. ) 3 S. Feinerman ( N.D. Ill. ): fed to Thomas ( 2013 ) Judge Robert (... State-Court judges with two or more former clerks on current law faculties law! Specific justices than in the same period at top-25 schools clerks on current law faculties tie ) S.! Webvideo message from Chief Judge Robert Katzmann ( 2d Cir. ) academic opportunities for recent and! 900 Article III federal judges, of course, has his famous team! Than the link between lower-court clerkship and SCOTUS clerkship Judge Daniel Calabretta and Second Circuit Nathan. A three-count counterclaim same period clerks on current law faculties John Paul Stevens Randall the. The money-and-geography axis jurist, helps district court feeder judges an academic position of more-recent district-court.! Spearheads the schools charge towards interdisciplinary, inclusive degree opportunities, I adopt the familiar parlance as analogy! Clerks in 35 years, while Elrod projects to 15 academic former.. H. Eid ( CO ): 4, 5 also Clerk for.... Clerk, perhaps with a strong recommendation from the jurist, helps an... Thapar published 631 ordersonly 11 of which were reversed on appeal strong district court feeder judges from the jurist, helps an. Dean Ken Randall spearheads the schools charge towards interdisciplinary, inclusive degree.! Include adjuncts and other part-time faculty who clerked for Justice John Paul Stevens Clerk SCOTUS...